In an unfortunate case of lost Bitcoin, where James Howells, a British man, is reportedly seeking 495 million British pounds ($647 million) from Newport City Council because they refused to let him dig up a landfill to recover a hard drive with 8,000 Bitcoin that he threw away more than 10 years ago. His claim for the error in his case had started as early as 2013 but the council has always rejected his attempts at trying to rectify the issue.

The value of the lost Bitcoin still continues to rise, which means that the stakes for Howells and Newport City Council are even higher now. Howells has accused them of neglecting his proposals that would make the landfill safe for excavation while the council has accused him of placing health hazards to the environment.

A $647 Million Lawsuit Over Lost Bitcoin

James Howells, an IT engineer from Newport, threw away the hard drive containing Bitcoin worth 8,000 in 2013 when its worth was really low. At the time, it is estimated that his online wealth was about £1 million ($1.3 million). Forwarding to 2024, those 8,000 Bitcoin are valued at almost 495 million pounds ($ 647 million).

Newport City Council has denied Howells’ application to undertake an excavation of the site to try and locate the lost Bitcoin drive for over a decade now. Still, the council did not change its mind about allowing the shoot by putting forward environmental concerns linked with interfering with the landfill site.

Howells and the council bring the case to court, Howells sue the council for 495 million pounds. “I have made several scenarios, and they all entail safe digging,” Howells said in the interview with *WalesOnline*. “I know there is no reason why the council cannot work with me on this, but all our efforts are being thwarted.”

Council’s Environmental Concerns

Newport City Council has recently supported its action to stop the excavation claiming that it poses several risks to the environment. The location where Howells’ hard drive is thought to be buried is listed for multiple violations of permits issued to the environment. The landfill contains unhealthy substances such as asbestos, arsenic and methane which the council says can pose further risks if the site is dug up.

In an official statement, Newport City Council explained their position: There are various materials that cause harm to the environment and that are likely to be released to the environment if the site is interfered with. Evidently, the safety of the public and the environment has to be protected.”

As for the further technologies which can be used, Howells mentioned robotic excavators and drones controlled by artificial intelligence to find the hard drive among 110 thousand tonnes of trash but the council didn’t approve them. This has been the case yet the council has on insisted on not accepting his proposals, they even rejected Howells offer to grant the council 10pc of the recovered Btc value in case of a successful excavation.

Technological Solutions and Unresolved Conflict

In 2022, Howells unveiled a recovery plan that incorporates technology, which would possibly cost $11 million to implement. This was not going to cost the council anything as some private entities were willing to fund the project. Specifically, the proposal entailed the utilization of intelligence robots that would go through the waste and accurately determine the position of the hard drive hence reduce on the pollution of the environment.

Lost Bitcoin

Even if Newport City Council has proposed the use of advanced technology, they continue their negative response. They thus challenge the legal and usability of the arguments that Howells advanced since even in a case that they found the drive, it may just be proved not to be working after being buried under so many tons of trash for years. Furthermore, the council offered objections toward legal exposures that they may incur due to the damage or environmental problems resulting from the excavation.

When questioned by the press, Howells voiced his disgust at the attitude taken by the council. “It’s frustrating because I’ve done everything I can to make this as safe as possible,” he said. “The technology is available, the money is available, they just don’t want to hear.”

Signs of a Long Legal Struggle Ahead

As the battle continues Howells has gone to court to try and seek civil redress to reclaim his lost bitcoin. The trial begins in December 2024; both sides are gearing up for what may be a long and complicated case.

In case Howells wins the case, Newport City Council might suffer a huge penalty, which will escalate the pressures on the local authority. On the other hand, the victory for the council will affirm protection of the environment from exploitative private interests and will send a strong signal of the role of council in such matters.

Final takeaway on Lost Bitcoin Trial

The legal case of James Howells suing Newport City Council because of a loss of $647m of lost Bitcoin from the environmental disaster proves that the environment and individuals’ money interrelate. Since neither is willing to budge, the case that is scheduled for hearing in December may possibly mark the end of the long-standing legal battle. For now, Howells’ dream of reclaiming his money lies in the landfill, and the decision of the case will determine the fate of other cryptocurrency-related cases in the United Kingdom courts. Keep following TheBITJournal and keep an eye on the legal battle for lost Bitcoin.

Follow us on Twitter and LinkedIn, and join our Telegram channel to be instantly informed about breaking news!